Cost vs Value: Best ROI Home Improvements

Cost and value are important factors to consider when determining the budget for a home improvement project. Cost versus value analysis compares how much you spend on a project to the increase the resale value of the property.

Home improvement costs consist of the price of materials and labor. The value of a home improvement project can be measured by an increase in the home’s property value.

This analysis is crucial for property owners and investors to maximize their property’s worth. Important factors for this assessment include location, workmanship quality and home improvement market trends.

Certain improvements may yield a higher ROI than others depending on the area. For example, a kitchen remodel might have a different cost-to-value ratio in a faster real estate market than a slower one.

Consider your goals and budget before committing to a project. Not all home improvement projects provide equal ROI. Some projects may have a high upfront cost, but only modestly increase property value. In contrast, simple and cost-effective upgrades such as adding insulation or improving the curb appeal of the home can offer great ROI.

Pro Tip: Read The Forecast to stay up to date on housing and home improvement markets, plan new projects effectively and understand current trends as they develop.

HVAC electrification has the highest ROI among the most popular home improvement projects. The average cost is $17,747 nationwide, and the average increase in resale value is $18,366. This means that the average HVAC conversion will offer a 103.5% ROI to the resale value of the home.

HVAC electrification may have a higher upfront cost than other home improvements, but the project offers several benefits that appeal to potential buyers.

For example, electric HVAC systems do not produce carbon emissions. This reduces the carbon footprint of the home and can improve energy efficiency with solar panels or wind turbines. Last year, energy-efficient homes made up about 9% of the housing market. Buyers looking to reduce their impact on the environment favor homes with this upgrade.

Modern HVAC systems allow for customization and a higher level of control. Heat pumps and variable speed motors can be adjusted to run slower or faster depending on the weather, time of day or when nobody is home.

Businesses can use these functions to save on energy and specify the ventilation for specific rooms. For example, a business owner can monitor which rooms of the office are used and at what time of day. They can use that information to schedule when the HVAC system heats and cools rooms based on when they are typically used.

Home automation options are becoming more widespread and would allow potential buyers to control their HVAC from their smartphone. This year, about 45% of current homes are actively using smart devices. Components like electric furnaces, boilers and air conditioners can be controlled via smartphone and smart thermostats.

That said, HVAC electrification comes with more challenges than some other projects and may not be an option in some areas. In addition to high initial investment, electrification presupposes the home can depend on the local electrical grid for power. Rural areas and inconvenient locations may make the process difficult or impossible, and renewable energy sources may not be available for every location.

Garage door replacements are the second most lucrative home improvement project. They ranked second in highest ROI, with a national average of 102.7% cost recuperated.

A garage is typically a prominent feature of a home’s facade and a key factor in curb appeal. An outdated or damaged garage door detracts from the home’s aesthetic appeal. A well-planned replacement can increase property value significantly.

The exterior of a home plays a crucial role in shaping the first impression of potential buyers and appraisers. A variety of materials, styles and finishes are available. Your choice can complement the home's design and boost curb appeal.

Modern garage doors are often better insulated and help maintain a stable temperature inside the garage. This not only improves energy savings but can appeal to buyers who may see the garage as a multipurpose space. It can be used as a workshop, home gym or additional living area, all of which benefit from better insulation.

New garage doors typically come with advanced security features that can give potential buyers peace of mind. Updated locking systems, garage door openers, reinforced materials and security cameras can be particularly effective in security-conscious markets.

Manufactured stone veneers are a popular siding choice for property managers and homeowners looking to enhance the appearance of their property. Projects like this have an average 102.3% ROI and are ranked third most cost-effective in the country. The average cost of a new veneer is $10,925 with an average resale value improvement of $11,177.

Using manufactured stone veneers are cost-effective compared to traditional masonry. Additionally, they can come in a wide array of styles suited for both interior and exterior home improvements.

One benefit of manufactured stone veneers is their ability to mimic the look and texture of natural fieldstone, granite, limestone and other materials. The selection of styles, colors and finishes gives property managers the freedom to adapt a veneer to the style of the property.

Manufactured veneers are significantly lighter than natural stone, which simplifies installation and reduces the need for structural modifications. Installation typically requires two days, which makes them a convenient choice for property owners on a tight schedule.

Manufactured stone is engineered to withstand the elements and resist fading, chipping and cracking. They are made to last for about 50 years and are non-porous, which have practical outdoor applications like siding and landscaping. Indoor applications are more diverse, and can apply to a variety of areas like fireplace surroundings, accent walls and kitchen features.

Steel entry door replacements rank fourth with an average 102.3% ROI, which places it right below manufactured stone veneers. This is one of the last improvement projects with an average ROI above 100%, meaning projects are less likely to recuperate their entire cost during resale. Keep in mind that improvement projects with less than 100% ROI may contribute to a higher resale value when combined with other projects and upgrades to the property.

The main advantage of a steel entry door is increased security. Steel doors are typically reinforced with a solid core and are resistant to forced entry attempts, which offers more peace of mind than a new garage door depending on the design of the home. Many steel doors are compatible with smart locks and customizable controls for another layer of protection.

Steel doors are durable and made to resist issues common with wood doors such as warping and rotting. They require minimal maintenance and will likely last the rest of the home's lifespan with regular cleaning and repainting.

Steel doors also offer strong insulation and resist drafts, which helps to maintain indoor temperature and reduce energy waste. This results in potential savings on heating and cooling bills. When replacing an entry door with a steel one, consider energy-efficient features such as foam insulation and weather stripping to maximize efficiency.

Consider the many design options available for steel doors like finishes and decorations to improve curb appeal. Property owners can use a steel door to match to the home's architectural themes or contribute to a new aesthetic in line with the property's other improvements.

Be more competitive and boost your bottom line with Pro Xtra, The Home Depot’s free loyalty program built for Pros. Sign up today to access the enhanced Pro Online Experience, built with the online business tools and time-saving features Pros need.

Create a quote, prepare bids and lock in pricing using a free Pro Xtra account. Simply fill your online shopping cart, log in to your Pro account and use the “Create a Quote” field at checkout.